Every once in a while some food idea crosses my mind that I file for future reference but quickly forget about. Later something will poke my memory and that idea will resurface.
We were in the grocery the other day and the store had a special on mini-watermelons. I know, what am I doing looking at watermelons in the middle of winter. I know they come from somewhere in Central America and their carbon footprint is heavy, but they looked pretty good and the price was good so I bought one …. so much for eating local.
Anyway, I saw those watermelons and into my head pops the idea of watermelon steak. Huh? Somewhere I had heard of such a thing and I thought it would be worth trying. If it didn’t pan out I figured at the very least we could add some to a salad or eat it fresh for dessert.
But, when I got home that idea of watermelon steak kept floating around in my head but I didn’t really know where to start so I did an internet search and, lo and behold, there are lots of sites that feature watermelon steak. Most referenced a restaurant near Boston called 51 Lincoln that seemed to have originated or, at least, featured a pan-seared watermelon steak as an appetizer or small plate.
If you have read our blog before, you know I’m always up for something different. This watermelon steak, as imagined by 51 Lincoln and repeated by many other blogs, certainly was a strange sounding dish and one I wanted to try.
I spent some time scanning the many variations. Some recipes called for marinating the trimmed blocks of watermelon in cream sherry overnight or at least for several hours. Some cooked the “steaks” on a grill or directly in a saute pan. But in many the “steaks” were roasted in the oven for 2-1/2 (yes, two and a half) hours at 350˚ F. I settled on a shorter marinade, 2 hours in the oven and a finishing sear in the saute pan. Here’s what it all looked like.
Now, most of you would probably think (I certainly did) that after that amount of time in the oven the watermelon would be cooked to a mush. But not so. Remarkably the melon held up quite well. It shrinks a bit but the color remains bright and the texture is transformed. The melon was no longer grainy the way fresh watermelon is. Rather it takes on a decidedly firmer texture not unlike the linear grain of fresh beef or raw tuna.
A strange dish but one worth trying, if for no other reason than to say you did.